snipe/app/trust/aggregator.py
pyr0ball bccedb1fe5 fix(trust): treat feedback_ratio=0.0 as missing data for buyer-only/returning sellers (#52)
eBay omits the 12-month positive percentage for returning sellers and
buyer-only accounts with no recent sales. Previously ratio=0.0 with
count>0 triggered established_bad_actor; now it returns None from the
scorer (score_is_partial=True) and emits a soft no_recent_seller_data
flag instead. ratio=0.0 with count=0 is still treated as no-history.
2026-05-04 09:24:27 -07:00

191 lines
8.9 KiB
Python

"""Composite score and red flag extraction."""
from __future__ import annotations
import json
from datetime import datetime, timezone
from typing import Optional
from app.db.models import Seller, TrustScore
HARD_FILTER_AGE_DAYS = 7
HARD_FILTER_BAD_RATIO_MIN_COUNT = 20
HARD_FILTER_BAD_RATIO_THRESHOLD = 0.80
# Above this lifetime count the 12-month ratio may cover only a tiny recent sample,
# making a hard bad-actor flag disproportionate. Instead we emit the softer
# "declining_ratio" flag and let the composite score carry the penalty.
# Note: buyer-feedback-only accounts (e.g. longtime buyers who start selling) are a
# related edge case that requires profile-page scraping to detect properly — tracked
# in snipe#52 as a medium-term fix.
HARD_FILTER_BAD_RATIO_MAX_COUNT = 500
HARD_FILTER_BAD_RATIO_HIGH_THRESHOLD = 0.60 # catastrophically bad even for high-volume
# Sellers above this feedback count are treated as established retailers.
# Stock photo reuse (duplicate_photo) is suppressed for them — large retailers
# legitimately share manufacturer images across many listings.
_ESTABLISHED_RETAILER_FEEDBACK_THRESHOLD = 1000
# Title keywords that suggest cosmetic damage or wear (free-tier title scan).
# Description-body scan (paid BSL feature) runs via BTF enrichment — not implemented yet.
_SCRATCH_DENT_KEYWORDS = frozenset([
# Explicit cosmetic damage
"scratch", "scratched", "scratches", "scuff", "scuffed",
"dent", "dented", "ding", "dinged",
"crack", "cracked", "chip", "chipped",
"damage", "damaged", "cosmetic damage",
"blemish", "wear", "worn", "worn in",
# Parts / condition catch-alls (also matches eBay condition field strings verbatim)
"as is", "for parts", "parts only", "spares or repair", "parts or repair",
"parts/repair", "parts or not working", "not working",
# Evasive redirects — seller hiding damage detail in listing body
"see description", "read description", "read listing", "see listing",
"see photos for", "see pics for", "see images for",
# Functional problem phrases (phrases > single words to avoid false positives)
"issue with", "issues with", "problem with", "problems with",
"not working", "stopped working", "doesn't work", "does not work",
"no power", "dead on arrival", "powers on but", "turns on but", "boots but",
"faulty", "broken screen", "broken hinge", "broken port",
# DIY / project / repair listings
"needs repair", "needs work", "needs tlc",
"project unit", "project item", "project laptop", "project phone",
"for repair", "sold as is",
])
def _has_damage_keywords(title: str) -> bool:
lower = title.lower()
return any(kw in lower for kw in _SCRATCH_DENT_KEYWORDS)
_LONG_ON_MARKET_MIN_SIGHTINGS = 5
_LONG_ON_MARKET_MIN_DAYS = 14
_PRICE_DROP_THRESHOLD = 0.20 # 20% below first-seen price
def _days_since(iso: Optional[str]) -> Optional[int]:
if not iso:
return None
try:
dt = datetime.fromisoformat(iso.replace("Z", "+00:00"))
# Normalize to naive UTC so both paths (timezone-aware ISO and SQLite
# CURRENT_TIMESTAMP naive strings) compare correctly.
if dt.tzinfo is None:
dt = dt.replace(tzinfo=timezone.utc)
return (datetime.now(timezone.utc) - dt).days
except ValueError:
return None
class Aggregator:
def aggregate(
self,
signal_scores: dict[str, Optional[int]],
photo_hash_duplicate: bool,
seller: Optional[Seller],
listing_id: int = 0,
listing_title: str = "",
listing_condition: str = "",
times_seen: int = 1,
first_seen_at: Optional[str] = None,
price: float = 0.0,
price_at_first_seen: Optional[float] = None,
is_blocklisted: bool = False,
) -> TrustScore:
is_partial = any(v is None for v in signal_scores.values())
clean = {k: (v if v is not None else 0) for k, v in signal_scores.items()}
# Score only against signals that returned real data — treating "no data"
# as 0 conflates "bad signal" with "missing signal" and drags scores down
# unfairly when the API doesn't expose a field (e.g. registrationDate).
available = [v for v in signal_scores.values() if v is not None]
available_max = len(available) * 20
if available_max > 0:
composite = round((sum(available) / available_max) * 100)
else:
composite = 0
red_flags: list[str] = []
# Blocklist: force established_bad_actor and zero the score regardless of other signals.
if is_blocklisted:
red_flags.append("established_bad_actor")
composite = 0
return TrustScore(
listing_id=listing_id,
composite_score=composite,
account_age_score=clean["account_age"],
feedback_count_score=clean["feedback_count"],
feedback_ratio_score=clean["feedback_ratio"],
price_vs_market_score=clean["price_vs_market"],
category_history_score=clean["category_history"],
photo_hash_duplicate=photo_hash_duplicate,
red_flags_json=json.dumps(red_flags),
score_is_partial=is_partial,
)
# Hard filters
if seller and seller.account_age_days is not None and seller.account_age_days < HARD_FILTER_AGE_DAYS:
red_flags.append("new_account")
if seller and seller.feedback_ratio == 0.0 and seller.feedback_count > 0:
# 12-month ratio missing from page — returning seller or buyer-only account.
# Score will be partial (metadata._feedback_ratio returns None). Soft flag
# only: do NOT fire established_bad_actor on what is likely missing data.
red_flags.append("no_recent_seller_data")
elif seller and seller.feedback_ratio < HARD_FILTER_BAD_RATIO_THRESHOLD:
if HARD_FILTER_BAD_RATIO_MIN_COUNT < seller.feedback_count <= HARD_FILTER_BAD_RATIO_MAX_COUNT:
# Moderate-volume account with consistently bad ratio → hard flag.
red_flags.append("established_bad_actor")
elif seller.feedback_count > HARD_FILTER_BAD_RATIO_MAX_COUNT:
if seller.feedback_ratio < HARD_FILTER_BAD_RATIO_HIGH_THRESHOLD:
# High-volume seller with catastrophic ratio → still hard flag.
red_flags.append("established_bad_actor")
else:
# High-volume seller with declining but not catastrophic ratio.
# 12-month window may cover only a small recent sample — soft flag only.
red_flags.append("declining_ratio")
if seller and seller.feedback_count == 0:
red_flags.append("zero_feedback")
# Zero feedback is a deliberate signal, not missing data — cap composite score
# so a 0-feedback seller can never appear trustworthy on other signals alone.
composite = min(composite, 35)
# Soft flags
if seller and seller.account_age_days is not None and seller.account_age_days < 30:
red_flags.append("account_under_30_days")
if seller and seller.feedback_count < 10:
red_flags.append("low_feedback_count")
if signal_scores.get("price_vs_market") == 0: # only flag when data exists and price is genuinely <50% of market
red_flags.append("suspicious_price")
is_established_retailer = (
seller is not None
and seller.feedback_count >= _ESTABLISHED_RETAILER_FEEDBACK_THRESHOLD
)
if photo_hash_duplicate and not is_established_retailer:
red_flags.append("duplicate_photo")
if (listing_title and _has_damage_keywords(listing_title)) or (
listing_condition and _has_damage_keywords(listing_condition)
):
red_flags.append("scratch_dent_mentioned")
# Staging DB signals
days_in_index = _days_since(first_seen_at)
if (times_seen >= _LONG_ON_MARKET_MIN_SIGHTINGS
and days_in_index is not None
and days_in_index >= _LONG_ON_MARKET_MIN_DAYS):
red_flags.append("long_on_market")
if (price_at_first_seen and price_at_first_seen > 0
and price < price_at_first_seen * (1 - _PRICE_DROP_THRESHOLD)):
red_flags.append("significant_price_drop")
return TrustScore(
listing_id=listing_id,
composite_score=composite,
account_age_score=clean["account_age"],
feedback_count_score=clean["feedback_count"],
feedback_ratio_score=clean["feedback_ratio"],
price_vs_market_score=clean["price_vs_market"],
category_history_score=clean["category_history"],
photo_hash_duplicate=photo_hash_duplicate,
red_flags_json=json.dumps(red_flags),
score_is_partial=is_partial,
)