MenagerieOS: evaluate Boot-Time Wizard for distro QA pipeline #40

New issue

Open

opened 2026-05-24 22:00:45 -07:00 by pyr0ball · 0 comments

pyr0ball commented

2026-05-24 22:00:45 -07:00

Owner

Background

Boot-Time Wizard is an alpha-stage embedded Linux tool from Tim Bird (Sony), presented at ELC 2026. It iteratively benchmarks one boot-time change at a time and asks a human to interpret results before proceeding.

GitHub: https://github.com/tbird20d/boot-time-wizard
Phoronix coverage: https://www.phoronix.com/news/Boot-Time-Wizard-Linux
Slides: https://hosted-files.sched.co/osselcna2026/e4/Boot-Time-Status-Bird-ELC-2026-v2.pdf

Relevance to MenagerieOS

MenagerieOS ships as a desktop distro for Windows/macOS migrants. First-boot experience matters: a slow boot undermines confidence in the migration decision.

Proposed use: Run Boot-Time Wizard during distro QA cycles (not user-facing) to catch boot regressions before shipping an ISO. The tool is designed for exactly this: iterative tuning on target hardware.

What to evaluate

Does it work outside embedded context (KDE Plasma target vs. headless embedded)?
Can it integrate into an automated ISO build pipeline, or is it manual-only?
Benchmark: baseline MenagerieOS boot time vs. stock Ubuntu/Mint on same hardware
Target: boot to desktop in under 20 seconds on reference hardware (i5/NVMe)

Not user-facing

Boot-Time Wizard is a developer tool. Robin will handle user-facing boot slowness detection via pattern matching (slow-boot-* patterns already added in robin#patterns-expansion). This issue is about the MenagerieOS build/QA side.

Status

Alpha (project). Revisit when MenagerieOS reaches distro packaging stage.

## Background Boot-Time Wizard is an alpha-stage embedded Linux tool from Tim Bird (Sony), presented at ELC 2026. It iteratively benchmarks one boot-time change at a time and asks a human to interpret results before proceeding. - GitHub: https://github.com/tbird20d/boot-time-wizard - Phoronix coverage: https://www.phoronix.com/news/Boot-Time-Wizard-Linux - Slides: https://hosted-files.sched.co/osselcna2026/e4/Boot-Time-Status-Bird-ELC-2026-v2.pdf ## Relevance to MenagerieOS MenagerieOS ships as a desktop distro for Windows/macOS migrants. First-boot experience matters: a slow boot undermines confidence in the migration decision. **Proposed use:** Run Boot-Time Wizard during distro QA cycles (not user-facing) to catch boot regressions before shipping an ISO. The tool is designed for exactly this: iterative tuning on target hardware. ## What to evaluate - [ ] Does it work outside embedded context (KDE Plasma target vs. headless embedded)? - [ ] Can it integrate into an automated ISO build pipeline, or is it manual-only? - [ ] Benchmark: baseline MenagerieOS boot time vs. stock Ubuntu/Mint on same hardware - [ ] Target: boot to desktop in under 20 seconds on reference hardware (i5/NVMe) ## Not user-facing Boot-Time Wizard is a developer tool. Robin will handle user-facing boot slowness detection via pattern matching (`slow-boot-*` patterns already added in robin#patterns-expansion). This issue is about the MenagerieOS build/QA side. ## Status Alpha (project). Revisit when MenagerieOS reaches distro packaging stage.